Don’t ask for recommendations from people you haven’t worked for

The fine line between personal and professional social media makes it hard for some to understand the function of either platform.

While Facebook is mostly for the three “F” crowd – friends, family & funLinkedIn is a network of professionals that communicate and socialize at a whole different level.

Earlier this year, I explained why it’s not a good idea to add connections on LinkedIn without analyzing their function in your circle of professionals.

In a hilarious twist that further defines the pitfalls of over-connecting, Tim Ash – founder and chairman of the social Conversion Conference – explains how a request for an employment testimonial by a mere connection, can lead to some unpleasant results:

“This may happen to you also if you ask for me for a LinkedIn work recommendation although you have never worked with me and we have not ever met…”

tim-ash-geoffrey-linkedin

Tim removed the LinkedIn recommendation after a few minutes, but not before ‘Geoffrey’ emailed him with a complaint; the latter act convinced Tim to post about the incident publicly. The debate, at this point, is whether he over-reacted, or if his reaction was justified. In my personal opinion, he was rather mild in his response.

The bottom line: Seeking professional endorsement from people you have not worked for, is the same as resume stuffing and can often get you in trouble – temporarily or otherwise.

 

Comments

  1. This LinkedIn recomendation is uselless, the first to recomend me for a skill written “SEO” for a reason I ignore and from there almost anyone placing a recomendation stupidely do the same and flagged me as a SEO expert.
    Some skills with domains, web development, … but SEO!!?
    Funny when I do not care about SEO, there is +7 now I not optimize any web page for SEO nor read any SEO blog nor follow what happen in the SEO world… and if you look at my profile you may think I am the SEO pro now 😉

  2. Francois 😀 The example is not about ‘endorsements’ that occur between contacts, but about actual recommendations of association or employment. E.g. if I worked on a design for you, I would be justified in asking an endorsement of employment. It’s a way to keep professional connections – well – professional.

  3. Damn! I just noticed you also recommend me as a SEO expert … LOL

  4. These endorsements are based on characteristics of your profile; you can edit it in such a way that only those which apply to you are included. 🙂

  5. Francois, AFAIK it’s because you’ve included SEO in your profile skills section. I wonder how it can help our profiles or LinkedIn in general when most of us lately just click “endorse all” hoping to hide a pop-up screen?

Speak Your Mind

*